A Cultural Shift

I hardly ever watch television anymore. However, I turned on the MLB playoffs last month, and I was shocked to notice something about the further degradation of our cultural morals in one of the commercials. A highly sexualized commercial suddenly appeared, advertising a sports “trading” or gambling site called Novig. Following my shock and disgust, I realized how many other commercials and sponsors were advertising other betting sites (FanDuel, DraftKings, BetMGM, Kalshi). Even embedded in the broadcast, announcers would occasionally sprinkle different odds or percentages into their commentary for what could or did happen during the game, signaling to viewers who might be interested in making a little coin while they watch. 

Gambling is now openly a part of major sports. For most of two centuries, gambling had been illegal and relegated to the secrecy of dark, smoke-filled rooms. It was largely looked down upon as the seedy underbelly of society, an activity that was relegated to a limited number of casinos or Indian reservations, a vice associated with scandal, addiction, and the mob. But it has now entered the mainstream of culture, accepted as a normal part of American life. And it isn’t limited to sports gambling. 

Kalshi, a “prediction market platform” launched in 2021, gives users the ability to “trade” (aka, “bet” or “gamble” or “wager”) on virtually anything. Individuals can place bets on sports, the weather, economic indicators, political and legislative results, who will win cultural awards, and even military conflicts. The idea is that you have opinions, often called “takes,” so why not put some money on them? 

Besides having access to the brothel in your pocket, the casino is now just a tap away. 

What’s the Big Deal?

Well, if you are a modern evangelical, you might not see anything wrong at all–it’s just another puritanical fence coming down because we have lost all appreciation for why it was there in the first place. Leslie Landrigan, writing for the New England Historical Society, opens her article with this acknowledgment: “The Puritans had barely arrived in the Massachusetts Bay Colony when they banned gambling.” Christian settlers, concerned with public morals, quickly saw gambling as something to outlaw, following the pattern of other Western countries like England, Germany, France, and Italy. As America developed, all U.S. states had laws against gambling. But it was Nevada, in 1931, that became the first state to legalize gambling, and in 2018, the Supreme Court overturned a federal gambling ban, which opened up the states to unleash it on their communities. Up until then, for the better part of two centuries, Christian America largely viewed gambling as an illegitimate and immoral way to make and lose money and believed it to be a vice that also led to many other social ills. 

Yet for years now, church groups have hosted poker nights (ask me how I know), pastors gamble on fantasy football, Christians gift each other lottery scratchers, believers regularly frequent the casinos in Las Vegas, and now, like porn, they are legally accessing gambling in the privacy of their handheld devices. Ask any conservative evangelical and most pastors, and you will almost universally hear that gambling is not sinful as long as you can afford it. $5 bets are no big deal. Nickel slots are cheap fun. It’s just entertainment like going to the movies. Putting a $20 bet on a baseball game and watching from home is seen as better stewardship than buying the $50 ticket to attend the game. To most people, it’s no different than trading stocks on the NASDAQ. The argument is that there is NOTHING wrong with it since everyone involved is a consenting adult or business, and as long as you keep it under control and it doesn’t “harm” your family, it’s not wrong. 

After all, there is no verse in the Bible that says, “you shall not gamble.” 

Have Christians become more godly and biblically consistent for the first time in history? Are we now finally living in the light of the freedom of Christ, out from under the superstitions and arbitrary opinions of the Puritans? Or have we become more worldly, despising our fathers, and have actually failed to accurately discern the Scripture and our hearts?

The Sin of Gambling 

The Bible does not directly mention gambling by name. But as long as you are not a legalist, that isn’t a problem for discerning Christians. The Bible doesn’t mention arson directly either, but that doesn’t mean we can’t draw lines to biblical principles and laws that help us to identify it as a sin. So, how is gambling a sin? 

First, gambling is a violation of biblical economic principles. In Scripture, there are righteous and unrighteous ways to exchange goods and services. Understanding this requires doing biblical theology. For instance, you may receive a product (money) as wages for work (Deut. 24:15), you may purchase a product or pay for a service (Lev. 25:14), you may give someone a gift (Matt. 2:11), you may borrow and return (Ex. 22:14), and you may give and receive inheritance (Prov. 13:22). In those forms of economic exchange, there are laws that provide regulation. You must not give or take from someone else what you have no right to give or take. For instance, you may not have “unjust weights and measures.” That’s cheating (lying and stealing). You must not give your money for the services of a prostitute because you have no right to receive what the woman is willing to give. Many, many more principles and laws are laid out for us. 

What is gambling? Phil Johnson’s 2009 blog gives this helpful definition: “When you gamble, you are risking money (or something else of value) on the outcome of something that involves an element of chance, uncertainty, or hazard—for the possibility of winning something someone else has put at stake.” And “a stake is a prize one person stands to gain through the loss of others.” Biblical economics presents a righteous economy built on love, with the free exchange of goods and services where everyone benefits. Gambling, however, involves winning through a game of chance at someone else’s loss. Gambling is a zero-sum game. It is unloving, regardless of whether the loser accepted the risk. People can lose their investment in a business or stock, for instance, but that is entirely different. It was the righteous investment of resources in the labor, the idea, the invention, the person, who hoped to grow a business for his own benefit and the ROI for the investor. 

While all of life involves risk or the lack of knowledge of the future, risk is not unrighteous on its face. Gambling is putting at risk one’s possessions for the sake of “chance,” hoping to take the resources of someone else so that they lose – and for nothing. And that prospect, it turns out, is exciting. The issue is not the playing of cards. The issue is that it becomes more exciting when we put money on it, because, whether it is $5 or $5 million, it touches a heart motive of covetousness and greed, and it is rebellious to God’s order for the righteous gaining of wealth (Prov. 13:11). Gambling is by nature an outward manifestation of covetousness, every time. Why? Covetousness is an unrighteous desire to gain what rightfully belongs to my neighbor in an unrighteous way. I can be righteously ambitious and gain an approximation of what belongs to my neighbor (wife, servant, ox, donkey) through getting my own wife, working, and engaging in commerce so that I get my own servant, ox, and donkey, and so wealth has been created. I can want what my neighbor has, and I can get it all righteously, but when I want him to lose and me to gain what he has, it is a violation of the 10th commandment. To challenge my neighbor to a game of chance in order to transfer what belongs to him to me is based on my covetous desire to divest him of what he has. 

All gambling involves this basic scenario, regardless of whether you know who your neighbor is or see his face, or whether he is anonymous to you through an app. Gambling is sinful because it’s a form of stealing (unrighteous economics, taking from someone what you don’t have a right to take) based on covetousness, through the means of a game of chance (even if some knowledge or skill is involved). No new wealth is created in the exchange; rather, it is a transfer of wealth from a loser to a winner. 

The House Always Wins

When we go outside of God’s good order and design, there tends to be a snowball effect. Sin comes in bunches. It is no surprise what is adjacent to the unleashing of a covetous heart in gambling. Sexual lust, cheating, violence, addiction, destroyed marriages, drunkenness, game fixing and point shaving, and all kinds of ungodly behavior. And young men, once again, are especially susceptible and in the crosshairs of the gambling industry. 

In talking with my 20-year-old son, who plays college football locally here in Idaho, he identified that his teammates are “obsessed” with gambling apps. But what nobody seems to appreciate is that the house always wins. Gambling apps are siphoning off the wealth of the nation (along with other culprits like Credit Card fees and usury). Kalshi alone has a valuation of $40 billion in just five years. Each “trade” involves a “small” (for now) fee. They have tapped into the covetousness of the people. Casinos don’t lose money. They always take their cut, and for what? What good or service is provided? Nothing of value. 

They are enticing and manipulating people to part with their finances. They only provide the opportunity to put at risk, for a fee, the wealth of individuals, families, and communities, and they take it out of that economy in order to enrich a few. Gamblers are suckers, and they contribute, with each bet, to their own demise, cultural rot, and the economic destruction of a people. It’s time that the church recovers its witness by calling out the sin of gambling, loving our neighbor, and refusing to play the world’s sinful games.